Wilderness areas protect wildness. If limiting their access achieves that, so be it. | Editorial | Bend | The Source Weekly - Bend, Oregon

Your support for independent local news is important.

The Source Weekly has been Central Oregon’s locally owned news outlet for over 23 years. We have always been the definition of "support local." Our success in navigating this new world is tied to the success we experience in pulling together for the common good.

Quality local journalism takes a group of dedicated reporters passionate about democracy and open government. This story is the result of our hard work, and in normal times, the result of the support of the advertisers in Central Oregon. In the age of COVID-19, however, that support has taken a hit—but that’s where you come in.

Before you read on, we ask you to consider becoming a member of our Source Insider membership program at bendsource.com/insider.

Support Us Here

Opinion » Editorial

Wilderness areas protect wildness. If limiting their access achieves that, so be it.


This month, officials from the Deschutes and Willamette National Forests announced their Final Decision in the Cascade Wilderness Strategies Project, aimed at addressing overuse around some of the most well-used trails in the area. Under the new plan, people will be required to obtain day-use permits at 19 of the busiest trailheads in the Mount Jefferson, Mount Washington and Three Sisters wilderness areas—including Tam McArthur Rim, Green Lakes, Todd Lake and Devils Lake/South Sister. Each trailhead affected will fall under a quota system, allowing only a certain number of permits each day during the summer months, starting in 2020.

Three Sisters Wilderness Area - WIKIPEDIA
  • Wikipedia
  • Three Sisters Wilderness Area

This is a sound move.

There's much that's yet to be decided—such as how much the permits will cost, and how many permits will be available in advance, versus how many will be available day-of—but according to the text of the Final Decision, that's part of the next phase of the project, as is required under federal guidelines.

It's clear that this decision wasn't taken lightly, and that public input played a role. For example, in the Draft Decision for the plan, released in November, 30 trailheads were on the list—a number officials scaled back when some expressed concern that it was too sweeping of a change.

Anyone who visits the trailheads that remained on the list knows that these trailheads are too busy during the summer months. If we're judging only on safety, limiting the number of people allowed to obtain a permit for the Devils Lake/South Sister trailhead to just 100 individuals—as the Final Decision lays out—is safer for hikers who have to navigate loose scree on the final miles of the summit trail.

Mount Washington from Blak Butte Ranch - WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
  • Wikimedia Commons
  • Mount Washington from Blak Butte Ranch

And then there's the fact that wilderness areas are meant to be preserved for wildness. According to the Wilderness Act of 1964, wilderness areas are defined as, "an area where the earth and its community of life are untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain."

As the Final Decision puts it, there's a "clear congressional mandate to preserve the wilderness resource for present and future generations." Wilderness areas are, primarily, areas where wildness is allowed to thrive. Too many humans in a wild place at one time make that difficult.

Forest managers in this area must have understood the "untrammeled by man" acutely, in developing this plan. Were we to ask one thing, we'd hope that the permitting process also comes with tips for protecting wilderness.

Central Oregon has an abundance of natural resources and wild places to be enjoyed, and this plan won't hinder people from getting out for a last-minute hike (there are many places to do so) or from enjoying free recreation (it already costs money to park at those trailheads, after all).

Mount Jefferson Wilderness Area - WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
  • Wikimedia Commons
  • Mount Jefferson Wilderness Area

But wherever people roam, we hope they roam responsibly, leave no trace and recognize that it's a great privilege to tread there. Wilderness is for wildness' sake, first and foremost.

As the region continues to grapple with explosive growth and a massive influx of tourists each summer, doing something to recognize human impact and to educate visitors around what they can do to protect wildness is one step in the right direction.

Add a comment